The Toronto Blue Jays have just suffered a major blow, missing out on key free agents. But don't despair yet! There's still a chance to inject some serious power into their lineup – and it comes in the form of a 49-home run slugger.
Getty
Eugenio Suarez should be very high on the Blue Jays list after striking out on Bichette & Tucker
After striking out on two highly sought-after free agents, the Toronto Blue Jays have an opportunity to knock one out of the park by signing Eugenio Suarez. Missing out on key players can be tough, but sometimes the best opportunities arise when you least expect them.
Let's rewind a bit. Bo Bichette and Kyle Tucker, two players the Blue Jays were reportedly eyeing, have inked deals with other teams. On January 15th, Tucker committed to a four-year contract with the Los Angeles Dodgers. Then, just a day later, on January 16th, Bichette shocked many MLB fans by inking a three-year, $126 million agreement with the New York Mets. This was particularly surprising given the widespread speculation that he was headed to the Philadelphia Phillies. But here's where it gets controversial... some fans are questioning Bichette's decision, wondering if he prioritized short-term financial gain over long-term team success. What do you think?
Now, you might think Suarez is just a consolation prize. But fortunately for the Blue Jays, he's much more than that. Despite some voices urging the Blue Jays to consider other free agents, like Cody Bellinger, Suarez deserves serious consideration. Toronto should extend him a contract, even if they believe they have internal candidates who could potentially fill the role. Think of it this way: Suarez provides immediate impact and proven power.
Toronto Blue Jays Swing and Miss on Bo Bichette, Kyle Tucker
The MLB offseason can be a whirlwind. Just moments ago, analysts and insiders were suggesting that the Blue Jays were in a prime position to potentially land both Tucker and Bichette.
Now, they've missed out on both. Imagine the frustration! But this is baseball; things change quickly.
Ultimately, both Tucker and Bichette opted for shorter deals with opt-out clauses. This gives them a significant advantage. Considering their age and the relatively weak free agent classes projected for the next couple of years, they could potentially re-enter free agency and command even larger paychecks than they just secured. It's a smart move for them, no doubt.
However, the Blue Jays shouldn't lose heart. They've already taken steps to improve the team significantly. The additions of Dylan Cease, Cody Ponce, Tyler Rogers, Kazuma Okamoto, Eloy Jimenez, and Rafael Lantigua will definitely bolster the major league lineup and add valuable depth. But is it enough? That's the big question.
Blue Jays Should Sign Eugenio Suarez
If there's one thing that defines Suarez, it's his ability to hit home runs. While the Blue Jays aren't exactly shy about swinging for the fences, their power numbers could definitely use a boost.
In 2025, the team boasted the highest batting average in the league (.265). But and this is the part most people miss... they ranked only 13th in home runs with 191. That's a significant disparity! This is precisely where Suarez comes into the picture. He's the missing piece to unlock the Blue Jays' offensive potential.
Suarez had a phenomenal 2025 season. He racked up 118 RBIs, 134 hits, and a whopping 49 home runs. Across the league, he ranked fourth in RBIs, 80th in hits, and fifth in home runs. Those are elite numbers!
To give you some context, George Springer hit 32 home runs, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. managed 23, and Addison Barger contributed 21. The Blue Jays aren't slouches in the power department, but after failing to acquire Bichette and Tucker, adding Suarez would represent a clear upgrade. He's not just a backup plan; he's a legitimate difference-maker.
Throughout his 12-year MLB career, Suarez has only hit fewer than 20 home runs in three seasons. In each of those seasons, he played fewer than 100 games. Furthermore, two of those three seasons were his first two in the major leagues. So, you can almost disregard those early years as part of his development. The remaining nine years tell a different story.
In six of those nine years, he's blasted at least 30 home runs. His 49 homers in 2025 marked the second time he's reached that impressive milestone in a single season. He's a proven power threat year after year.
The slugger has primarily played third base but also has experience at first base. There's no reason to believe that Suarez couldn't adapt and become a capable second baseman for the Blue Jays. His versatility adds even more value.
What Would it Cost to Add Eugenio Suarez?
A Blue Jays team featuring Tucker or Bichette would have been a formidable force. However, those deals would have come with hefty annual average values (AAV). Fortunately, signing Suarez would cost a fraction of their price tags.
MLBTradeRumors projects Suarez's next contract to be around $63 million over three years. The Athletic, on the other hand, predicts a $69 million, three-year deal for the 34-year-old slugger.
To put things into perspective, Tucker's signing bonus with the Dodgers is reportedly $64 million. So, adding a home run machine like Suarez to the batting order for roughly the same price would be a worthwhile investment for Toronto.
According to Spotrac, Suarez's market value is approximately $15 million per year. Considering the Blue Jays' need to compensate for the lost offense from missing out on Bichette, combined with Suarez's proven power, he could be a highly underrated and impactful addition. But here's a thought: is focusing solely on home run power the right strategy, or should the Blue Jays prioritize other offensive skills like on-base percentage and stolen bases?
With the hopes of landing Tucker and Bichette dashed, the Blue Jays must remain focused on improving the team. And in the case of Eugenio Suarez, that improvement could be substantial.
What do you think? Would signing Eugenio Suarez be a smart move for the Blue Jays, or should they pursue a different strategy? Share your thoughts and opinions in the comments below!
Caleb Kerney covers the NHL for Heavy.com. He has covered professional hockey since 2022, including bylines at Dobber Prospects, The Hockey Writers, and The Hockey News.
